Scapho's Blog



Subscribe!

If you'd like to be notified automatically when a new blog article is posted then subscribe here.

To Photoshop or not to Photoshop? That is the creative question

Saturday, 30 September 2023

The use of Photoshop oir similar tools to manipulate photos is a controversial subject amongst photographers. How much is too much?

I’m often asked if my work is “photoshopped”. There seems to be an automatic expectation that anything unusual or particularly creative in a photo has been added or manipulated after the shot was taken. I’ve frequently been asked this about my own picture “Downtown Atlanta, early Sunday morning”; people find it hard to believe that the red car wasn’t added retrospectively. However, I can assure you that the picture is exactly what I saw when I opened the hotel curtains that morning.

Moving from a specific picture to my work in general, I always answer the question in the same way – I do use an editing tool to make basic “tweaks” to my photos, but I don’t add or remove anything, and I don’t significantly manipulate the image.

I’ve been taking photos since I was given my first camera at the age of nine, way back in 1965. When I was about 15 a teacher at school began running darkroom sessions at lunchtimes for anybody who was interested, and I began to learn the art of developing and printing photos. It was there that I first experienced the magic of watching an image appear on photographic paper as I gently rocked it in the developing dish. Even now I find it an amazing experience.

Over the years my darkroom skills improved, and I learned all the little tricks that could turn a good picture into a great one. Some were basic: cropping a picture to achieve a balanced composition, adjusting exposure and contrast to get something more pleasing to the eye. I also learned more advanced techniques such as “burning” and “dodging-in” to selectively darken or lighten parts of the image.

Around 2004 I started to switch to digital photography, and by 2008/2009 I was shooting almost exclusively with a digital camera. Of course, this meant that editing photos became a job for the computer instead of the darkroom. It also opened up a whole new world of possibilities for editing my photos which I’d never had before, either because I didn’t have sufficient darkroom skill to try them or because they were simply impossible outside a computer.

Like a child with a new toy, I embraced them in a frenzy of enthusiasm, but my fervour soon faded. The images I’d created didn’t satisfy me. They seemed artificial. Of course, this is a ridiculous thing to say – any photo is artificial, but somehow the more I processed my images the less real they became. It was at this point I made a fundamental decision about how I would approach editing my work. I decided that I would use editing tools only to make changes that I could have made in a darkroom. I have kept to that simple rule ever since.

The whole subject of heavily photoshopped images is, of course, intensely controversial and I don’t propose to reopen the debate here. I have no objection to images created in this way, but it doesn’t appeal to me. I also think heavily manipulated images shouldn’t be pitched against “straight” photographs in competitions. They are a separate genre requiring a different skillset and so they should be judged separately. I will continue to treat my digital editing tools as a basic darkroom and nothing more.

No comments yet
Search